Humans + AI

Human executive assistant vs AI assistant: what should each one do?

AI tools draft, summarize and suggest meeting times for $10–30 a user a month. A human EA owns judgment and follow-through. What to give each, and how to combine them.

Short answer

Give AI tools the first draft: replies, summaries, meeting notes and suggested times, for about $10 to $30 per user a month. Give a human executive assistant everything that needs judgment, relationships or accountability: what is urgent, what to say to a board member, what to book and what to escalate. The strongest setup is a human EA who uses AI, with clear rules on what they can send without your approval.

Why executives are looking for help now

Microsoft's 2025 Work Trend Index found that the average worker receives 117 emails a day and 153 Teams messages per weekday. For the most-interrupted fifth of users, a ping arrives every two minutes during core hours, 275 times a day. Of all meetings, 57% are ad hoc calls without an invite, and nearly a third span several time zones.

Over half of leaders (52%) say their work feels chaotic and fragmented. Both AI tools and assistants promise to fix this; they fix different parts of it.

What AI assistants do well, and what they cost

AI assistants are fast and cheap at producing a first version: a reply, a summary of a long thread, notes from a call or a proposed schedule. These are the published prices of common options.

ToolPublished priceWhat it does
Microsoft 365 Copilot (enterprise)$30 per user / month, paid yearlyDrafts and summarizes in Outlook, Teams, Word; needs a qualifying Microsoft 365 license
Microsoft 365 Copilot Business$21 per user / month (promotion: $18), paid yearlyThe same assistant for smaller companies
Google Workspace with GeminiStandard $14, Plus $22 per user / monthGemini in Gmail, Docs and Meet
Reclaim.ai$10 to $22 per seat / monthSchedules focus time, habits and meetings automatically
Motion$19 to $29 per seat / monthPlans your day and tasks around your calendar

Prices read on each vendor's page on October 28, 2026. Google showed an introductory discount for new customers.

Where AI tools fall short on their own

  • Accountability. A tool cannot be responsible for a missed flight or a message sent to the wrong person. Someone still has to check its work.
  • Context and politics. Knowing that one investor always gets a call back the same day, or that two board members should not be seated together, is not in your inbox.
  • Relationships. Other executives' assistants, hotels and partners respond to a person who knows you.
  • Follow-through. AI drafts the follow-up; it does not chase the person who never replied.
  • Sensitive work. Contracts, HR matters and confidential deals should not pass through a tool without a human deciding what goes where.

Who should do what

TaskAI tool aloneHuman EA using AIWho approves
Inbox triage and repliesDrafts replies, summarizes threadsDecides priority, writes in your voice, follows upEA sends routine replies; you approve sensitive ones
Scheduling across time zonesSuggests slots, blocks focus timeNegotiates with other assistants, resolves conflictsEA alone
Meeting preparationSummarizes documents and past emailsBuilds the brief, checks facts, chases missing materialEA alone
Travel and logisticsSearches optionsBooks, rebooks on disruption, knows your preferencesYour OK above a spend limit
Contracts, HR and legalSummarizes for readingRoutes to the right people and keeps it confidentialHuman only
Follow-upsSets remindersChases people and closes the loopEA alone

How approval modes keep you in control

At Hedly you set, once and per task type, one of four modes: AI drafts it, EA sends alone, needs your OK or human only. Routine replies and scheduling usually run on their own; travel above a limit needs your OK; contracts and NDAs stay human only. Every action is logged, and the Friday report adds up what was done, by whom and when.

When an AI tool alone is enough

If you get a few dozen emails a day, run your own calendar and rarely travel, an AI tool may be all you need. Once you are spending hours a week on scheduling, travel and follow-ups, or a mistake would cost a relationship, a human EA pays for itself. See what an executive assistant costs.

Frequently asked questions

01Will AI replace executive assistants?

AI is replacing the drafting part of the job, not the judgment, relationships and accountability. The EAs in demand are the ones who use AI to do more in the same hours.

02Is it safe to give an AI tool access to my inbox?

Use only tools your company has approved, and decide what can be sent without you. At Hedly, EAs sign NDAs, access is managed and logged, and legal, HR and key relationships are never handed to an AI tool.

03What is an approval mode?

A rule you set once per task type: AI drafts it, the EA sends alone, it needs your OK, or it stays human only. It decides what goes out without you.

04Is a Hedly EA a person or an AI?

A person. Your EA uses AI tools to work faster, but every decision and every message is theirs, and they answer to you.

Sources

  1. Microsoft WorkLab — Work Trend Index: Breaking down the infinite workday (June 2025)
  2. Microsoft 365 Copilot — Enterprise pricing
  3. Microsoft 365 Copilot — Business pricing
  4. Google Workspace — Pricing
  5. Reclaim.ai — Pricing
  6. Motion — Pricing

Published: · Updated:

Keep reading

Get your week back.

Tell us what you want off your plate. We will introduce you to 3 EAs within 24 hours.